Harry Potter's Girlfriend

Melissa Hung
July 27, 2005

Now that Harry Potter #6 is out, I'm reminded of the ongoing controvery over Harry Potter's love interest, Cho Chang. I haven't read any of the books, so I'm wondering what those of you who have think about it.

Some people think it's a good thing to have an Asian featured so prominently in the story. Others think she's just another stereotype and point out that her name doesn't make a lot of sense. Apparently she is supposed to be Chinese. So why a Korean surname for her first name?

People have also been complaining about Katie Leung, the unknown Scottish actress who is playing Cho in the movie version. I'm not sure what the complaint is actually -- she hasn't done anything yet. Some people think she's not attractive enough for the part and are hating on her online. (Of course there are plenty of fan sites too.) Here's a story about it that ran a few months back. I can't believe people in the story below (I would link to it, but you have to register. Blah) questioned whether or not she could speak English. Um hello, she attends a prestigious prep school. What do you think?

***Cyber-spite over Harry's girl
By Annabel Crabb
April 24, 2005
The Sun-Herald

Harry Potter's choice of girlfriend has set off a global internet backlash with ugly racial overtones.

Katie Leung, a 17-year-old Scottish girl of Chinese descent, was recently announced by Warner Brothers as their successful applicant for the role of Cho Chang in the forthcoming film Harry Potter And The Goblet Of Fire.

Cho Chang, a sorceress, delivers Harry Potter's first screen kiss in the film, the fourth in the hugely successful series. But the unknown actress is now the target of an internet hate campaign.

Hate Katie Leung sites have been established by jealous Potter fans, while chat sites last week ran hot with criticism of her looks and Asiatic background.

"Katie is a beast. She looks like a monster, not the love interest of my Daniel Radcliffe!" said a correspondent on the Asian American Film chat site.

Elsewhere, correspondents asked whether Katie could speak English.

Warner Brothers will not allow interviews or photographs with their new star while the film is in production.

Teenage actor Daniel Radcliffe, who plays Harry Potter, was more enthusiastic about his new screen paramour, describing her as "very pretty and cool".

Katie's father Peter, a food wholesaler based in Lanarkshire, said he was proud of his daughter but frightened at the savagery of the response.

"I can't make any sense of it, although I know how popular Harry Potter is," he told the Daily Star newspaper.

"No one knows her, has seen her or heard her speak, yet there all these things on the internet. Unfortunately she has seen them, too. She reads them all and it is a great pressure on her."

Tags: 
yellowfevermedia
yellow fever
Contributor: 

Melissa Hung

Founding Editor

Melissa Hung is the founding editor of Hyphen. She was the editor in chief for the magazine's first five years and went on to serve in many other leadership roles on the staff and board for more than a decade. She is a writer and freelance journalist. Her essays and reported stories have appeared in NPR, Vogue, Pacific Standard, Longreads, and Catapult, among others. She grew up in Texas, the eldest child of immigrants. Find her on Twitter and Instagram.

Suggested Reads

Does Childish Gambino Have an Asian Problem?
LAAPFF '12: Can an Asian Fetish Lead to True Love?

Comments

Comments

Christiana wrote on Sat, 11/19/2005 - 11:49am
I never really thought about race in the Harry Potter books. I never even thought about the fact that the Patil twins were Indian; it didn't matter for me. I believe the people who say Cho is ugly have a very limited view of beauty. Besides the fact that it is rude to point out someone else's physical ills, it is also unkind. The detail that her hair is not long enough isn't even important. Does Emma Watson have large enough teeth as the book describes? I don't believe so. There are a lot of blogs out right now that accuse Rowling of portraying Cho Chang stereotypically Asian: smart, attractive, fair-skinned. But if the character was anything else, i.e. ugly, stupid, and dark, you can bet there would be an even bigger riot. I am half-Chinese, and I consider myself myself to be relatively intelligent, attractive, and fair-skinned. It is not Katie's fault she looks that way. It is also not her fault that her character's name is under so much controversy. I feel sorry for the kid.
Christiana wrote on Sat, 11/19/2005 - 11:50am
I never really thought about race in the Harry Potter books. I never even thought about the fact that the Patil twins were Indian; it didn't matter for me. I believe the people who say Cho is ugly have a very limited view of beauty. Besides the fact that it is rude to point out someone else's physical ills, it is also unkind. The detail that her hair is not long enough isn't even important. Does Emma Watson have large enough teeth as the book describes? I don't believe so. There are a lot of blogs out right now that accuse Rowling of portraying Cho Chang stereotypically Asian: smart, attractive, fair-skinned. But if the character was anything else, i.e. ugly, stupid, and dark, you can bet there would be an even bigger riot. I am half-Chinese, and I consider myself myself to be relatively intelligent, attractive, and fair-skinned. It is not Katie's fault she looks that way. It is also not her fault that her character's name is under so much controversy. I feel sorry for the kid.
Christiana wrote on Sat, 11/19/2005 - 11:51am
The previous message was messed up a bit. I posted it again

Pages