Hyphen Lynks: "Model Minority" My Ass! Edition

September 16, 2009

  • Rep. Ahn Joseph Cao RepublicanFail: the dude is too liberal for his own party, and too conservative for his constituents. He's even considering voting for Obama's health care package. "Model Minority" my ass!
  • And finally: compare the comments on this New York Times blog post on raising a bilingual child to Hyphen's own two-part blog post from Momo a few months ago. Hyphen's discussion is so much more complex and rich than the NYT's (not surprisingly in any case.) But it's really obvious that the reason for the Hyphen-extra-richness is that the NYT's commenters are mostly monolingual parents in transnational/interethnic marriages trying to raise a bilingual child, whereas Hyphen's commenters are mostly folks who were raised bilingual, or partly raised bilingual, themselves. This is typical of white America: have a question? Ask other white Americans who have the same question. Don't, for gods' sake, ask the minorities who have the answers! This is why we SOOO need Hyphen. Hyphen magazine: "Model Minority" my ass!
Contributor: 

Comments

Comments

I just read the NYT article and the Hyphen posts and while I agree that the Hyphen comments are a lot more interesting, I don't understand your claim that NYT's commenters are "mostly monolingual parents in transnational/interethnic marriages" and mostly white. From what I saw, a lot of them grew up in immigrant households, come from different ethnic backgrounds, were raised speaking more than one language and, I thought, had interesting things to say.
Maybe it's time to change our tagline to"Model minority my ass"